Skip to Content

RETROSPECULATIVE TV: Babylon 5: “The Gathering” (Pilot 1993)

Republibot 3.0's picture

Babylon 5 was, beyond any shadow of a doubt, the best American SF show since the original Star Trek, and the most influential. Though never amazingly popular here in the states, pretty much every genre program since has owed at least an indirect debt to ground plowed and made fallow by it. Joseph Michael Straczynski conceived of it as a five year ‘novel for television,’ an arc-based program with a definite beginning, middle, and end, and while the hype is, as ever, hyped and somewhat unbelievable, he did, in fact, accomplish most of what he’d intended, though not really in the ways he intended it ( http://www.republibot.com/content/hidden-evolution-babylon-5 and http://www.republibot.com/content/hidden-evolution-babylon-5-part-ii-%E2... ) Though it’s since stumbled through several ill-fated spinoff/revival attempts, and been overshadowed by flashier, more popular productions, it holds up really well, far better than any of its peers from the era, and it’s still a pretty compelling, complex, fascinating story.

It is, however, rather daunting for newbies to jump in to. I mean, there’s something like a hundred and thirty-five hours of B5 and B5-related stuff, set in a completely new fictional universe that pretty much no one knew anything about at the time. It was threatening for Trekies then, and a huge investment of time for people with only mild curiosity now.

We’re going to be going through the series slowly, looking it over, and pointing out things of interest for the benefit of any of you out there who want to follow along. I had *intended* to do the entire franchise, including books and comics - in chronological order with the episodes, but that has quickly proven to be too daunting a task for me, so we'll just do our normal Retrospeculative treatment.

PLAY BY PLAY

Babylon 5 is a massive space station five miles long, orbiting a planet in the Epsilon Eridani solar system, ten and a half light years from earth. ( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Epsilon_Eridani ) It’s a La Grange colony ( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trojan_points#L4_and_L5 ) built on a heavily-modified O’Neil Cylinder design ( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/O%27Neill_Cylinder ) Nearly a decade earlier, there had been a massive space war between Earth and an alien race called the “Minbari” which very nearly rendered our species extinct. In the hopes that such wars could be avoided in the future, the earth Government decided to build a space station in neutral territory, located more-or-less evenly between earth and the four other major alien governments: The Minbari, the Narn, the Centauri, and the Vorlon.

It’s function is basically a diplomatic establishment, but it also functions/pays the bills by working as a free trade port, and there’s lots of traffic coming through all the time. Think of it as a kind of United Nations located in Casablanca, and you’ll get the feel they’re going for here.

The whole “Babylon Project” hasn’t exactly been prosperous thus far. The first three attempts to build a Babylon space station were destroyed by internal sabotage, the fourth one appeared to be going fine, then disappeared without a trace 24 hours after being completed. (These are all details that’ll pay off later in the run of the series) Babylon 5 was, hence, built on a shoestring budget, and without a lot of confidence that it would work, or even survive. (Which is a clever way to explain the threadbare sets, since the series itself was run on a shoestring budget, and without a lot of confidence on the part of many people) Thus, even before we get going, the station is somewhat beleaguered by real-world problems like money, public confidence, trade patterns, government contracts, political tension, and stuff like that. That may not sound like much nowadays, but in a decade dominated by the sterile Maoist utopia known as Star Trek, it was both revolutionary and a breath of fresh air.

As the show starts out, the station has been up and running for a month or three. Representatives from three alien races are already on the station - Minbari, Centauri, and Narn - and the fourth and final one - the Vorlon - is en rout. Earth is represented by the guy who actually runs the station, Commander Jeffrey David Sinclair, who is, himself, a veteran of the Earth/Minbari war.

Literally within a minute of coming on board the station, Ambasador Kosh - the Vorlon - is the victim of an assassination attempt, and is in a coma. This happens shortly after a Telepath arrives on the station at roughly the same time Sinclair’s girlfriend does, so they both seem suspicious,

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Republibot 3.0
Republibot 3.0's picture
Offline
Joined: 12/27/2008
Oh yeah!

Oh, yeah, I forgot about that one! It was one of the hour-long episodes. I tend to forget those exist.

The Artist Formerly Known As Republibot 3.0

neorandomizer
neorandomizer's picture
Offline
Joined: 06/27/2009
Maybe not the first

>>Arguably, B5 was the first SF show ever to really deal with that. I suppose "The Wounded" from TNG kind of touches on it - that beat B5 by several years - but this was the first one to really make it a major, ongoing plot point. Had Sinclair stayed on the show, it would have figured pretty prominently in his character arc - learning to overcome it - and even once he left the show it was still a pretty prominent element in his infrequent returns.<<

Their was an original Twilight Zone episode that dealt with this. A Chief Petty Officer is the sole survivor of a US submarine from WWII and when they find the wreak he thinks he is hearing his shipmates calling to him.

Republibot 3.0
Republibot 3.0's picture
Offline
Joined: 12/27/2008
Survivor's Guilt/PTSD

Actually, it was more like 30,000 went in, and only 200 survived.

It's interesting that Sinclair never wore his medal for that, and even his girlfriend didn't know he'd been in it. I also liked his line about how, for years after the war, whenever he saw a Minbari he had to resist the urge to strangle the life out of them.

Garibaldi said he'd seen this before, Marines from his unit who survived the war, but were just kind of broken and empty afterwards, "People looking for a cause to die for because it's easier than finding something to live for."

Arguably, B5 was the first SF show ever to really deal with that. I suppose "The Wounded" from TNG kind of touches on it - that beat B5 by several years - but this was the first one to really make it a major, ongoing plot point. Had Sinclair stayed on the show, it would have figured pretty prominently in his character arc - learning to overcome it - and even once he left the show it was still a pretty prominent element in his infrequent returns.

The Artist Formerly Known As Republibot 3.0

neorandomizer
neorandomizer's picture
Offline
Joined: 06/27/2009
The price of war

>>Could be. Definitely he had a lot of religious elements to him. But he was too stolid. One thing I really *did* like about him was that he was always rushing off into harms way - fighting the Ikaran warrior, or the Minbari Windswords assassin, or other things - generally Captain Kirking his way around. And then Garibaldi points out that Sinclair is exhibiting clearly suicidal behavior. To which Sinclair responds, "Holy crap! You're right!" (I paraphrase)<<

Survivors guilt with a little PTSD thrown in he was at the Battle of the Line where 20k went in and only 2k came out that would screw anyone up. They are seeing a lot of this now with our troops so it is a true depiction of the toll that fighting in a war has on a person.

Republibot 3.0
Republibot 3.0's picture
Offline
Joined: 12/27/2008
Oh, well there you go...

>>>I remember there was the race that eats carrion and that everyone keeps away from because they smell bad.<<<

Yeah! The Pak'ma'ra. I love them. Also exhibited EXTREME sexual dimorphism. I didn't see that as a cultural thing, though, just a biological one. (And kind of hilarious: "Guess what the Pak'ma'ra say Narn tastes like?" "Chicken? Man, I hate this job.")

>>>There was the race of parents who were very religious and didn't believe in modern medicine (I think they show up just the once tho).<<<

"Believers." It was never made clear if their whole world was like them, or if they were just individual religious fanatics. You could have put Christian Scientists or Seventh Day Adventists in there, and the plot would have worked just as well.

>>>There was a race that hunted souls, and another one that launched raids to capture races to perform cruel experiments on.
I can't think of any others off the bat, so maybe there weren't too many after all<<<

Ah, yeah, there you go: you're right. The Soul Hunters are definitely portrayed as monolithic. Not specifically evil - the first one we meet is insane, the one that shows up hunting him is far more willing to listen to reason. And Martin Sheen was actually likable - but unquestionably you're right about them, and I'd forgotten, thanks!

The "Streib" kidnapping aliens are portrayed as pretty bad, too, though they make it fairly clear that ship is just a raiding party.

>>>Almost all the Narn we see are angry, susceptible, and violent; and almost all the Centauri we see are indolent, proud, and condescending.<<<

True. The Narn, as a species, were hungry, lean, and close to the bone, lashing out after a century of slavery. The Centauri were the Roman Empire (Or possibly the French one) on the cusp of decline, most of them not really grasping what was happening to them. ("See the mighty Centauri Republic, open 9 to 5, earth time") In their case, though, I think it sets up the disastrous consequences of them trying to regain power.

>>>And there were the random alien races who have ambassadors at Babylon 5 (the non-aligned league), but those guys don't actually do or say hardly anything.
I guess a certain amount of all this is just the way it had to be because it's no Lost and they can't develop dozens of characters. But they could have just not had them in the first place and the overall story wouldn't really have suffered.<<<

I think you needed them. The place was supposed to be busy, and I think they really needed to flesh out that there were *lots* of aliens, with varying levels of power and tech. They mentioned that there were 250,000 people on the station, half of whom were Aliens, half of whom were Minbari, Centauri, and Narn, the remainder were from the "Nonaligned worlds." They mentioned that the Centauri and Minbari were providing substantial money to keep B5 operating. It was kind of an "International Space Station" I think they needed the place to be exotic, and part of that was having Gaim wandering around, and Drazi picking fights, and Na'Grath the bug dude functioning as a kind of alien Godfather. There's a deliberate Casablanca atmosphere.

>>>Yes, that was actually explained quite well. On the other hand, a diplomatic station isn't the most logical place for people (or aliens) to go to get a new start when they fall on hard times. The station (the "last best hope for peace") is absolutely essential to preserving our race (and others too presumably)--and on top of it, the place is supposed to be full of high level diplomats holding vital meetings, etc--so it seems there'd be some quality control when people arrive, or at least a much more efficient security system to move them on when things don't work out.<<<

Casablanca, again, I think. It's a diplomatic station, but it also functions as a free trade port, and given that it's centered between the five major governments, it's in a natural trade rout. They get scores of ships every day (Notice how quickly things get backed up when there's a crisis and Ivonova can't park ships). An upcoming episode is built around how busy the place is, and the toll it takes on the more blue-collar workers.

(And how cool is that? Blue Collar workers in space? Suck on that, Trek!)

I think, given the amount of traffic, the large population, and the relatively small military presence (10,000 or so), the place was probably a boomtown when it first went on line with people heading there to get jobs in the orange groves and eat chicken fried steak, if you follow my meaning.

The Artist Formerly Known As Republibot 3.0

Republibot 3.0
Republibot 3.0's picture
Offline
Joined: 12/27/2008
St. Sinclair

>>>The number of alien races did seem to be there just for crowd scenes but I did not find it distracting. Over all they portrayed the aliens better than most sci-fi does were they are just exaggerations of Earth cultures. (See Star Trek.)<<<

I think what he might have been saying is that B5 was really only interested in five alien races, and the others were far less defined. (My favorite being the Pak'ma'ra, but the most well-developed of the also-rans were the Drazi)

>>>Sinclare was portrayed as a priestly man trained by Jesuits and I believe they over played that aspect of the character sometimes.<<<

Could be. Definitely he had a lot of religious elements to him. But he was too stolid. One thing I really *did* like about him was that he was always rushing off into harms way - fighting the Ikaran warrior, or the Minbari Windswords assassin, or other things - generally Captain Kirking his way around. And then Garibaldi points out that Sinclair is exhibiting clearly suicidal behavior. To which Sinclair responds, "Holy crap! You're right!" (I paraphrase)

The Artist Formerly Known As Republibot 3.0

Scorpious
Scorpious's picture
Offline
Joined: 05/11/2010
Races and one-way tickets

>>Apart from the Drazi, I can't think of any monolithic alien races. And the Drazi weren't all good or all bad or all poetic or all jackasses, they were just more aggressive than most other races. Was there anyone in specific you're thinking of? The Drakh, maybe? There's just so many races it's entirely possible I've forgotten someone obvious...<<

Well, like I said, I saw this a few years ago, so I might have just blocked out of memory the races that weren't so central to the overall plots and then wondered why they were still around, heh.
I remember there was the race that eats carrion and that everyone keeps away from because they smell bad.
There was the race of parents who were very religious and didn't believe in modern medicine (I think they show up just the once tho).
There was a race that hunted souls, and another one that launched raids to capture races to perform cruel experiments on.
I can't think of any others off the bat, so maybe there weren't too many after all :-)
On the other hand, although G'Kar and Londo are individuals who evolve and change over time, the rest of their races are pretty monolithic. Almost all the Narn we see are angry, susceptible, and violent; and almost all the Centauri we see are indolent, proud, and condescending.
And there were the random alien races who have ambassadors at Babylon 5 (the non-aligned league), but those guys don't actually do or say hardly anything.
I guess a certain amount of all this is just the way it had to be because it's no Lost and they can't develop dozens of characters. But they could have just not had them in the first place and the overall story wouldn't really have suffered.

>>I think the indigents and lurkers and whatnot *were* overused, particularly in the 1st season, and to a lesser extent in the 5th, but they actually *did* explain several times why this was the case: "Lots of people come here looking for a new start, it doesn't work out, and they don't have the money to get back home again." I think this is supposed to fit in to the larger Economic arc that is touched on a few times in the series, but never really specifically spelled out: We're told a few times that the economy back home isn't good, and that there's quite a bit of poverty there, as well.<<

Yes, that was actually explained quite well. On the other hand, a diplomatic station isn't the most logical place for people (or aliens) to go to get a new start when they fall on hard times. The station (the "last best hope for peace") is absolutely essential to preserving our race (and others too presumably)--and on top of it, the place is supposed to be full of high level diplomats holding vital meetings, etc--so it seems there'd be some quality control when people arrive, or at least a much more efficient security system to move them on when things don't work out.
It's not the best examples, but people don't wander into the UN or Camp David looking for a new start, and if they do have a reason to be there for work or whatever and then lose that reason, then they can't go there anymore. And Babylon 5 by its nature and location should be pretty easy to monitor. The least they would do is make sure visitors/workers/etc have ongoing or return tickets when they arrive so that they don't ever have anyone without the resources to get home. It's kind of dangerous to let people in to such a high-profile place on one-way tickets and then lose track of them.

Anyhow, definitely looking forward to more B5 :-)

neorandomizer
neorandomizer's picture
Offline
Joined: 06/27/2009
One of the best

The thing I liked most about B5 was the events in one episode had consequences in following episodes. Their were no real filler episodes that you get in some episodic shows a seemingly small detail always seemed to come up later.

As for the lurkers I have read novels that had that aspect in some of there asteroid/ habitat sittings so it seemed natural to me. (see the books set in the Downbelow Station universe.)

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alliance-Union_universe

The number of alien races did seem to be there just for crowd scenes but I did not find it distracting. Over all they portrayed the aliens better than most sci-fi does were they are just exaggerations of Earth cultures. (See Star Trek.)

Sinclare was portrayed as a priestly man trained by Jesuits and I believe they over played that aspect of the character sometimes.

Republibot 3.0
Republibot 3.0's picture
Offline
Joined: 12/27/2008
Gotta' cover it

Hey, it's my favorite '90s show, and probably my 2nd-favorite show of all time. And as it's over 10 years old, there's no reasonable excuse *not* to watch it.

I think the indigents and lurkers and whatnot *were* overused, particularly in the 1st season, and to a lesser extent in the 5th, but they actually *did* explain several times why this was the case: "Lots of people come here looking for a new start, it doesn't work out, and they don't have the money to get back home again." I think this is supposed to fit in to the larger Economic arc that is touched on a few times in the series, but never really specifically spelled out: We're told a few times that the economy back home isn't good, and that there's quite a bit of poverty there, as well. I think part of the reason everyone was so quick to embrace president Clark was that he "Did away with poverty," though as we find out later he pretty much redefined it and swept undesirable people under the rug.

Once the story really gets going, there's lots of refugees on the station, at one point so many they threaten to overwhelm the place. Oddly, they don't make as big a deal about that (in Season 4) as they do about the lurkers in downbelow in seasons 1 and 2. Go figure.

There's some threads there that make it make sense, but they never really draw 'em together, presumably so JMS can do more "mad bomber" plots.

But yes, no getting around it, season 1 is slow. What kept me going when I first watched it was that it was *interesting* slow. I enjoyed watching a new world unfold logically, rather than them just winging it from week to week like very other show ever did. And while I get what they were going for with Sinclair, and while he's got a few good scenes (Oddly, mostly physical stuff, like the time he can't quite get his jacket on while his comlink is bleeping), he's wooden and stiff and evidently kind of a nightmare to work with, poor guy: Clearly they didn't really get what they were going for. (And notice how little he figures in to a lot of the later episodes that year).

Apart from the Drazi, I can't think of any monolithic alien races. And the Drazi weren't all good or all bad or all poetic or all jackasses, they were just more aggressive than most other races. Was there anyone in specific you're thinking of? The Drakh, maybe? There's just so many races it's entirely possible I've forgotten someone obvious...

The Artist Formerly Known As Republibot 3.0

Scorpious
Scorpious's picture
Offline
Joined: 05/11/2010
My B5

Yay. I'm glad you're doing this show.

I watched the first season within a few days back some years ago when I was too sick to go to school :-) I'm glad I did it in one go, because, as you pointed out, it's really quite slow and almost tedious in parts. I HATED Sinclair's completely wooden face, and I was glad they got rid of him by the time s02 started. His story was fine, but the acting was awful IMO. Then again, I was sick, so maybe he just got on my nerves.

I think a lot of effort was put into developping the main characters into believable people with reasonable reactions to stuff that happens, and that's definitely commendable. On the other hand, besides the "main" human and alien characters, there are heaps of (mostly alien) races and individuals who are grouped as "belligerant," "greedy," "cowardly," "not to be trusted," "smelly," etc, which isn't much better than Trek's races. Most of them are totally useless to the story anyhow and mostly just walk around in the background, except when their particular "type" is required to make a point. (This is especially apparent once the Alliance storyline gets started and the non-essential aliens just sit around the Alliance chamber nodding their heads.)

In the same way, some of the grittiness of what goes on in the station usually seems a bit put on, for the sake of whatever the episode requires. A space station has got to be the easiest place to keep "undefiled" from outside influences--not to mention that as a diplomatic station, it would require an even higher level of security than more regular stations like DS--and it just doesn't make sense that there'd be the amount of illegal immigrants and crime that goes on there. Those kinds of stories made more sense in BSG, for instance, because the whole point was that those people were randomly picked and randomly thrown together, which isn't the case for B5. I think Babylon 5 could have lost the huge amount of random people and areas that had no reason to be there and just focused on the core stories. They did that a bit better in the next seasons, but the first and last seasons especially had lots of stories that weren't so interesting as far as advancing the central themes, IMO.

I personally found Londo to be more interesting than G'Kar throughout--especially once G'Kar becomes a bit of a guru he sort of loses his personality IMO. Not that he should have always remained the angry, bitter, conniving, something-of-a-villain alien that he was at the beginning, but I just don't think that his particular metamorphosis improved him very much: from a storytelling point of view, he kind of lost a lot of potential.
--But I'm not dissing him! I think he's pretty great, but I do like Londo :-)

[[SPOILER:]]
--Oh, and maybe you'll eventually get around to explaining how Delenn's hair is supposed to work with her external cranial bones. It's never looked right to me.

A friend bought all the B5 dvds recently, and maybe this'll spur me to watch them again :-)

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Status

Bleeding Heart does not have a status.

Latest Status Updates

Republibot 2.0 Adding to the difficulty of this task- Libertarians tend to be the least likely group to 'swashbuckle' (liberate?) anything Randian. 30 weeks ago
Republibot 2.0 @nwkeys01 Weird. Both our 'art house' theater and our humongo-megaplex are screening it here. 30 weeks ago
nwkeys01 or like an old library book you might have read while you were a kid, and its impossible to find.... ex. Circle of Magic by Debra Doyle 30 weeks ago
nwkeys01 I know.... but its not widely released... Like in books, I know an author that feels offering them free reduces pirates and gains publicity. 30 weeks ago
Republibot 2.0 @nwkeys01 That's rather ironic... given that Rand's philosophy was "no cash, no service.." :) I'll see what I can find... 30 weeks ago
nwkeys01 where can I watch ASII online for free. that's the only way I'll be able to see it 30 weeks ago
nwkeys01 please do an update for "Don't vote for Romney" I don't particularly like him, but I have some other Republican friends to convince 30 weeks ago