INTERVIEW: John Varley
The following interview contains some coarse language, non-conservative viewpoints, and anti-religious sentiment. It is really cool and interesting, however. If these kinds of things offend you, do not read further, however if they do not it is well worth your time to read on. While we here at Republibot are conservatives, we feel that it is extremely important to ask questions and listen to all the answers before making up one's mind, and that simply can not happen if there are no dissenting viewpoints. Hence, when someone is kind enough to grant us an interview, it is our policy to let them say whatever they want without bugging them about it or censoring them.
PLEASE NOTE:
Read at your own risk
.
-------------------------------------------
Republibot 3.0:
Our guest today is John Varley, author of the Gaea Trilogy, the Mars/Thunder Trilogy and of course his ongoing Eight Worlds series. In the course of his career, Mister Varley has racked up two Nebulas, three Hugos, and an impressive ten Locus awards. He is clearly one of the brightest lights of his generation of Science Fiction authors, and entirely too impressive and important a man to be wasting his time speaking with the likes of us. And yet here he is!
Thank you, John, for agreeing to this interview.
John Varley:
No problem. The trilogy is actually called Thunder and Lightning, and there will be a fourth book in the series. What’s the word for that? Tetralogy? Quadrology? Whatever. The title will be Dark Lightning.
Republibot 3.0:
Before we get started, I want to say that it’s a sin more of your stories haven’t been turned in to movies. "The Funhouse Effect" just by itself would make a great SF thriller, and the fact that no one has turned "Red Thunder" in to a movie yet just drives me nuts.
Varley:
I’d probably do better with Hollywood if I wrote comic books … sorry, I mean "graphic novels" … but I never enjoyed them, even as a kid, except maybe for Uncle Scrooge. Superheroes bore me. I sometimes think that if I ever watch another comic book movie like Sin City, I’ll puke kryptonite. … I’m sorry, I meant graphic novel.
3.0:
On that note, I really like the way you occasionally use film as a touchstone in your books. In particular, I loved the way you used it in "Golden Globe." In addition to being a really great story, it has that underpinning of being almost a love-letter to classic Hollywood. That got me to thinking about the feedback loop that existed between the real Mafia in the old days and the Big Screen version of them back in the day. You had real life Gangsters emulating Edward G. Robinson, and then the actors started emulating the ever-more iconic Gangsters who were emulating them in the first place.
Do you feel there’s a situation like that in SF today? Where literary SF tries to emulate the movies, and the movies try to emulate literary SF? Does that get problematic for an author?
Varley:
I don’t read much SF, so I really don’t know about that. In the movies, gangstas are still either imitating movie bad guys, or the other way around, I’m not sure. That silly business of holding your pistol sideways, apparently to spoil your aim, the way they dress, and so on. The really silly thing is middle-class teenage white boys imitating ghetto kids with the gigantic, baggy pants so the piece they are carrying is not so obvious. As if they were actually carrying. I’d like to watch when these kids are 50 and take a look at pictures of themselves in these stupid outfits. "What was I thinking?" Pictures of me from the ‘70s look pretty silly, but not as bad as these kids.
3.0:
There’s a mini-renaissance going on with Science fiction on TV these days: Lost, the new Battlestar Galactica, the new Doctor Who, Terminator, the Stargate franchise, do you keep up with any of that? Are there any shows you follow?
Varley:
Not a one. I’ve heard that some of them are good, but I really know nothing about any of those shows. I watch very little regular television, though I spend a lot of time in front of the set. I watch DVDs of movies almost exclusively.
3.0:
What would you *like* to see happen in SF film and television, if you had your druthers?
Varley:
My stuff, of course. Golden age SF by Heinlein, Sturgeon, Silverberg, Ellison. Character-driven stories rather than plot-driven stories. Spider Robinson’s Callahan’s tales
- Republibot 3.0's blog
- Login or register to post comments
Mon, 03/09/2009 - 14:27
#2
Sturgeon's Law
"So it's a mixed bag. For every "Star Trek: The New Voyages/Phase II" you get, there are a hundred "Turkish Star Trek" episodes, you know?"
The same is true for 'original' fiction. Ninety-some-odd percent of *everything* is crap.
(Check out Starship Exeter. Most faithful recreation of TOS-era Trek, IMHO.)
Sun, 03/08/2009 - 11:10
#3
I wouldn't accuse him of a lack of imagination
I've read most of his books, he deserved those awards he won. Also, consider that most of his short fiction was written away back in the 70s, when he was just blowing the doors off of his competition in that department.
But, yes, it is entirely possible to write good stuff that launches from other people's work. I disagee with him there to an extent, but not entirely. Take a look at the Bond books that Ian Flemming wrote, then compare them to the endless John Gardner novels - crap. Yeah, it's updated for the 'modern era' but still: crap.
On the other hand, look at the Oz books - Baum died after writing like 18 or 19 of 'em, and Ruth Plumelly Thompson took over, and wrote like 20 or 22, and her books were (Generally) better than Baum's originals. Then after she died, other people started writing 'em, and those are pretty much terrible. And of course by then the copyright was lost, so anyone who wanted to could wright an Oz story, so suddenly you had a spate of hardcore Oz pornography coming out, and even that weird Heinlein hommage to Oz in "The Number of the Beast." If Bob couldn't really do it justice - and he legitimately loved those books as a kid - I'm thinking the spark of inspiration has been lost.
So it's a mixed bag. For every "Star Trek: The New Voyages/Phase II" you get, there are a hundred "Turkish Star Trek" episodes, you know?
Sat, 03/07/2009 - 21:26
#4
Distinction without difference
"He [Varley] was saying he didn't understand the drive to use *other* people's characters. "
Yes, his lack of imagination was what I was put off by. Maybe he should read "Le Morte d'Arthur" or "The Wind Done Gone." Too taxing? He could watch a Disney film festival.
Building upon the works of others is the basis for creativity. Sure, it can be done poorly, but it can also be done sublimely. Get the government-granted monopolies out of the way and let's cull the best of them.
Sat, 03/07/2009 - 18:53
#5
Yeah, Absolution can be absolutely absolving at times
Oh, no, I don't count those. Firstly, nothing ever got written down, secondly the point was not to make Brisco and Jim West kiss or anything like that, and thirdly, it was a mind experiment to see how a couple dead franchises could be relaunched while retaining the continuity of both.
It was pretty gay, though, in retrospect. Not in a Torchwood kind of way, I mean just in the embarasingly silly sense of the word.
Sat, 03/07/2009 - 16:12
#6
BTW...
This post was linked to by http://fancinematoday.com/ !
Thanks guys!
Sat, 03/07/2009 - 16:11
#7
I feel absolved...
No, I've not done anything like that- unless you call our Brisco County/Wild Wild West mashup/blueskying fanfic....
Sat, 03/07/2009 - 16:08
#8
Didn't figure you were
I specifically stated spec scripts are exempt. That's a legitimate attempt to fill a need and do business n' stuff. It's not just writing stories about making Kaylee and Inara kiss.
The TOS/1999 crossover you wrote definitely counts as fanfic, but you were what, like ten when you did that? I used to work my own name in to Hardy Boys books when I was that age - we all do horribly embarasing stuff like that when we're young. I think you're off the hook, there.
It's not like you've done anything like that since, right?
Sat, 03/07/2009 - 13:54
#9
I'm not talking about the script
The DS9 script I wrote wasn't fanfic; it was an actual unsolicited submission. A complete script... not a pitch.
(I wonder if I still have it. We might run it as original fiction; except it isn't... )
I'm referring to the infamous grade-school epic where the original crew of the Enterprise encountered the Space:1999 folk.
Sat, 03/07/2009 - 13:32
#10
Varying Degrees Of Ripping People Off
Well, I think there are different levels of fanfic. ("Fanficery?" "Fanfickery?")
F'rinstance, there's a difference between "Wanting to play in someone else's garden" and simply wanting to continue the adventures of classic characters. In the first case, you want to - let's say - tell stories exploring Larry Niven's Known Space universe; in the latter case you want to actually *write* your own Beowulf Schaefer stories set in Known space. There's a difference there.
Or to put it in a fan-film perspective: Telling original stories involving original characters set in the Trekiverse is kind of like Starship Exeter http://www.starshipexeter.com/ while telling new stories involving the established characters of the trekiverse is yet another, sort of like the Phase II peopel are doing http://www.startreknewvoyages.com/
And then telling stories where a thinly-veiled version of the author turns up and saves the day, and all the established characters fall in to his/her orbit is yet another, and the lowest circle of fanfic hell is unquestionably shipping and slash.
Sad.
Conversely, I don't think coming up with your own idea for an episode, and then writing it up as a pitch for the producers counts as fanfic.
Sat, 03/07/2009 - 01:35
#11
<raises hand guiltily>
"While I've never written any fanfic, I've been tempted to do so."
I have. But I've never written slashfic or a Mary Sue story.
rb2
Sat, 03/07/2009 - 01:23
#12
He wasn't saying that
Varley wasn't saying he had a problem revisiting his own characters and settings - he's done it a lot: his 8 Worlds series is sprawling and interconnected, and his "Thunder and Lighting" and "Gaia" trilogy are obviously picking up where the previosu book in that series left off.
He was saying he didn't understand the drive to use *other* people's characters. He's never felt compelled to write a Captain Kirk story, for instance (And he once told me they offered him a Trek move in the 80s, but he turned it down), or a Known Space story or what have you.
I'm not sure I agree. While I've never written any fanfic, I've been tempted to do so.
Fri, 03/06/2009 - 20:51
#13
Infringment is just another word for 'get off of my lawn'
"I can’t imagine why anyone would want to use somebody else’s characters to make a story or a film."
Putting aside, say, the Thieves Guild, Berserker, Known Space, and ten or twenty other series... many, if not most, genre authors like to revisit at least their own worlds. The reason is simple: you don't have to spend a lot of time introducing the place and characters.
An author who can't bring himself to acknowledge that fact is either disingenuous or so steeped in the current copyright quagmire that his fingers should be pruning.
Sat, 02/28/2009 - 01:48
#14
Intelectual Property
If you're a writer, I imagine you'd have some respect for other people's characters, and expect other writers to have some for your own. The idea of playing with someone else's stock character could seem dauntingly intimate, in addition to hackneyed.
Varley says he'd rather use someone else's toothbrush, but I myself was comparing it to borrowing someone else's underwear - you just don't want to do it.
I think the 'legal obligatons' arose from that consideration.
Fri, 02/27/2009 - 22:00
#15
Color me dense...
I'm not quite sure what you mean by that.
(No offense, there are some days that I just don't "get it"..)
Thu, 02/26/2009 - 23:26
#16
Hrmm.
Half very interesting interview, half subject-concerned-about-legal-obligations.
Status
Bleeding Heart does not have a status.
Latest Status Updates
| Jake Was Here Bunch of French spammers clogging up the forums. God only knows why. 21 hours ago |
| nwkeys01 anyone willing to review the tv show "Once Upon A Time", I've heard it's good, but I'm not good at making reviews, and haven't seen it yet. 3 days ago |
| nwkeys01 surprised the N.C amendment was called to a vote. Based on supreme court cases and 14th amendment it is unconstitutional. 3 days ago |
| Ginrummy Obscure science joke: "Dr. Schrodinger, you got a package in the mail today. I took the libery of opening it. Why did you order a dead cat?" 4 days ago |
| Ginrummy There's a HUGE spider in my house. So do I deal with it or just let it stay and eat some cockroaches? 1 week ago |
| Jake Was Here Conservatives hating on MLP? Where do we go from here? 1 week ago |
| shhhimbatman YJ ep 24 review up. I'm trying to catch up now. It's good to be back. 1 week ago |
| Ginrummy Vin Diesel says new "Riddick" movie (which just finished filming) is on track for a tentative release date of January 2013. 2 weeks ago |
| Scorpious wants to buy R3 a beer 2 weeks ago |
| Ginrummy I'll go to France and ask someone to "do something 'French' for me." They'll probaby just say "Stupid American!" and I'll reply "Thank you!" 2 weeks ago |
| Ginrummy XKCD cartoon for Altas Shrugged at http://xkcd.com/1049/ 2 weeks ago |
| Scorpious @Republibot 3.0 My birthday too ;-) 2 weeks ago |
| Republibot 3.0 Today is Larry Niven's birthday. He's 74. 2 weeks ago |
| SheldonCooper @Republibot 3.0 No you didn't, we just had a Dave and Maddie moment 2 weeks ago |
| Republibot 3.0 Well, it would appear as though I really screwed the pooch this time on the forums... 3 weeks ago |
Actually, I've been trying to get in touch w/ the Exeter people for quite a while now. I've sent 'em 2 emails in the last month asking 'em for interviews, but haven't heard back.
I even went so far to post here http://www.starshippolaris.com/forums/showthread.php?t=18282&page=11 to troll for people who might be able to put us in contact with them.