Skip to Content

EPISODE REVIEW: Defying Gravity “Venus” (Episode 12)

Republibot 3.0's picture

Our Exclusive-by-Default coverage of Defying Gravity continues with this, the show’s penultimate episode. To all our visitors from Canada and the UK, we bid you welcome.

PLAY BY PLAY

In 2047:

The Ascans are facing the first cut - of the 30 of them in the program, ten will not survive to the next round. We’re told that Zoe and a couple others are on the cusp, but Eve wants Wassenfelder on the mission for some undisclosed reason, which means someone else has to get bumped.

Zoe wakes up to see a big bald eagle hovering over her window. She goes in to the space center nervous, knowing she has little chance, and sure enough, she’s cut. She takes the news apparently quite well, and more-or-less brushes off everyone else’s condolences. Nadia, of course, was ranked #1. That night everyone (Excepting Zoe) heads to Major Toms to celebrate, but Nadia tells Donner that he’s no fun, and can go if he wants. He wants. He leaves - to Nadia’s obvious disdain - and then he and Zoe evidently knock spaceboots all knight long. The next morning, the eagle is back, so she kicks Donner out saying, essentially, “If I can’t be an astronaut, then I can’t stand to be around people who are.” He leaves. Evram and Claire finally hooked up the night before as well.

Several of the others show up to help her move, and lug all her crap to the train station. She’s got five hours to kill, and sees some people with a lot of tattoos, so she decides to get one. It’s a massive Eskimo eagle dealie, which she wants done all in one session, and so the tattoist gets started.

In 2052:

Nadia and Donner didn’t have sex. Neither did Paula and Wassenfelder, obviously. Both spent their nights chastely in each other’s arms. Zoe assumes otherwise (Naturally) and teases Donner about it. Jen, meanwhile, gets bitchier and bitchier, and is almost deliberately trying to drive Rollie away, and though she recognizes something is wrong with him, she doesn’t care what it is. In a rare non-pissy moment, she does tell Zoe that she would die if she had to live without her.

Nadia, meanwhile, is continuing to have hallucinations of herself with a baseball cap and a beard. In one of these, the doppelganger looks at her rather accusingly I think. Paula, obviously rattled, asks Wassenfelder if he believes in Miracles, and he says “Miracles are just the stuff we know with pieces missing” (Which fits Paula’s situation to a T) and the two of them get in a discussion of faith culminating with him saying that the most religious, faithful people he knows are physicists, who’s work convinces them there’s a higher power.

Claire, meanwhile, defies orders (Go, Claire! Yes! Finally someone in this show who does the right thing!) and tells Evram about the “Genome Changes” they’re experiencing. Evram is very upset by this, but they agree to conspiratorially keep watching the changes, as there’s nothing more they can do. Meanwhile, on earth, the English reporter dude is sensing a story, and he’s pushing hard to get details from AJ and Arnell.

The mission has a very short clock: they can’t stay on the surface for more than 20 minutes or else the caustic atmosphere will start to disintegrate the lander. Zoe’s mobility is limited to about 100 meters. They also don’t want people on earth to see “Gamma”, so they conspire (Groan) to fake part of the landing - one half of it will be real stuff, the other half will be stock footage of the team scuttling around in Arizona, gussied up with some special effects. (Extra groan!) Paula reacts not at all well to this, but rolls with it. She says a prayer for the mission.

The lander goes down, and they loose contact with the ship during entry (why?) and are getting a massive crosswind, and they land more than 200 meters from Gamma. They’re screwed. They resign themselves to collecting some rocks, but then Zoe hears a baby crying, and goes off following it, straight to Gamma on foot, but there’s no way in hell she can get there and back before the heat and pressure and acidic atmosphere kill them all…

To Be Continued…

OBSERVATIONS

Man, this was an unusually smarmy episode - a lot more smut-talk than usual, a lot more overt dialog using words like “Screwed” and stuff that weren’t allowed on TV just a couple years ago. It wasn’t terribly

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
10000li
10000li's picture
Offline
Joined: 10/23/2009
"Penultimate" is correct after all!

Hey, and here I thought that our host was misusing the word, "penultimate" as many folks do - thinking it applied to the last of something, not the second to last.

I didn't realize that there was a 13th episode! Thanks to nwkeys01 for giving us the link!

Thanks also to the folks at channel131.com who are "scketchy" on copyright law...

nwkeys01
nwkeys01's picture
Offline
Joined: 08/22/2009
channel131

http://www.ch131.com/dgseason1.htm
has a list of all episodes
clicking on the episode will take u to the video

http://www.ch131.com/defyinggravity113.htm

Republibot 3.0
Republibot 3.0's picture
Offline
Joined: 12/27/2008
Send me the URL?

Great, thanks nwkeys! Send me the URL, and I'll have a review up ASAP

The Artist Formerly Known As Republibot 3.0

nwkeys01
nwkeys01's picture
Offline
Joined: 08/22/2009
new epsidoe out now

new episode is up on Channel 131

now THAT was a season finale
love/honor/obey was NOT a season finale

10000li
10000li's picture
Offline
Joined: 10/23/2009
Fanfic, further

What I'm planning is a blog or an aggregator for posting fanfic by me and others. As I say, starting with DG and moving from there to anything and everything, with one or two caveats:

It should be PG-13 friendly, or at least no more explicit than the work from which it is derived.

No "Kirk kissing Spock" kinds of things, unless the characters have exhibited such amorous attraction in the original work.

The goal is to provide an "exercise space" for people to practice writing as if they worked for the show, or the publisher, or the studio. Writers can take an existing script and improve it and/or write the scripts that should have followed after the show in question was cancelled, and/or interpolate episodes that should have come between scripts, and/or create backstory. Also, if someone wants to create a "spinoff" based on a favorite character from the original work.

The idea, as I said, is to give writers the opportunity to work in side the constraints of what is logical for the show/movie/book/comic/game. Pro writers do it all the time - look at most of Dean Wesley Smith's work, for example, and of course all the other novelists who write Star Trek books, as well as anyone who writes episode scripts.

Everything posted would belong to the writer per applicable copyright laws, etc.

sysadmin 2.0
sysadmin 2.0's picture
Offline
Joined: 12/23/2008
Fanfic

I handle the hosting chores in a kinda-sorta but not really do-it-yourself setup.
Your fanfic clearing-house idea sounds interesting. Tell us more, and how can we help?

10000li
10000li's picture
Offline
Joined: 10/23/2009
firewall!

I have to decide if signing up for the IMDbPro "free trial" is worth it for me to get the contact info for James D. Parriott Products (who may not even own the scripts, at this point).

I'll decide on it later, but soon.

Buzz Aldrin and John Barnes' excellent hard SF book, "Encounter with Tiber" has a scene describing a bailout by a shuttle crew, and plots that one of the crew does not survive.

I'm thinking also about setting up a fanfic site for DG to start, but adding other shows, movies, and series I or the other writers like over time.

Who is your bloghost?

Republibot 3.0
Republibot 3.0's picture
Offline
Joined: 12/27/2008
Welcome, 1000

Astronauts (And Cosmonauts) are surprisingly superstitious, or possibly just OCD, and hence there's been this trend to do exactly what the previous guy did, since we know it worked. For instance, Alan Shepherd had steak and eggs for breakfast prior to his first (of two) launches, and became the first American in space. Every astronaut after him had the same breakfast up through the start of the Shuttle program as a kind of 'good luck charm.' A lot of them still do it, though it's not universal anymore. As a result, a lot of the Capcom chatter was surprisingly repetetive, even though it wasn't scripted or formal. Some of it was simply pilot-speak, which is rather formulaic to begin with, and some of it was "Well, I told the last guy I'd see him on the other side," and he didn't die, so I know that didn't anger the spacegods, so I'll say it again to the next crew.

In both the Apollo and Shuttle programs, the "Abort to Space" idea was pretty damn dangerous. In Apollo, they'd end up in an unplanned orbit around the moon, with no fuel, hoping the CM could recover them, but with no gurantees. In the Shuttle program, it would mean a very unstable orbit, probably they'd only get between 1 and 3 passes, and have to make an emergency landing. With that few orbits to orient yourself, it makes it unlikely that you'll get to land at one of the 'normal' landing sites (Edwards or KSC), so they'd have to go for one of the emergency backup sites in Africa or Spain, or maybe even ditch in the ocean. Either way, they assumed the loss of the Orbiter, and probably the deaths of the crew. (After Challenger disaster, these emergency landing procedures were updated to involve the bailing out of the entire crew, excepting [circumstances depending] the pilot)

That's painful to hear they've trashed the sets. I really loved those. It would have been nice to see some other production canibalize them, like the new BSG did with the LIS pilot sets (Which became the Battletar Pegasus). They were beautiful sets. If I ever get a chance to helm my own show, I'm hiring their set designer. It's a shame someone didn't do a virtual tour of 'em before striking 'em.

"Warehouse 13" is just on a summer break. It's been signed to a 22-episode season next year, so no worries there. A novel, or series, to wrap up the DG story would be a great idea!

Check IMDb for Mr. Parriott's contact info, and suggest the idea to him. Sometimes it works. James Hewett Wolfe wrote a one-act play explaining what he'd hoped to do with "Andromeda" before they fired him, which was pretty cool. That's a good idea about asking him.

The Artist Formerly Known As Republibot 3.0

10000li
10000li's picture
Offline
Joined: 10/23/2009
around the arc of the planet?

Based on the comments and reviewing the A-11 landing the DG Venus landing is derived from, it does seem the writers were trying to create a little tension from the ionization blackout. Even Rollie's quote "godspeed and see you on the other side" comes straight from the Apollo missions.

Actually, I wasn't even thinking about the ionization blackout, but that perhaps they were traveling around the arc of the planet and the radio signals were eclipsed.

Regarding the "abort to space" idea: There was a problem of that nature with a probe that went to one of the asteroids. It was to skim the asteroid and scoop up some dust into a collector, but the radar system got "scared" by too close of an approach at the wrong vector and blasted the probe away from the planet. The probe therefore didn't have enough fuel for the other maneuvers that were originally planned.

The latest I've read is that the DG sets have been destroyed and trashed, per "TVSquad"

Time to write some fan fic and tie-in novels... for DG, "New Amsterdam," "Warehouse 13," (not yet cancelled but on hiatus), and all those other great shows I find on Hulu after they've already been cut.

I don't think Paula's problem was an abusive, but that perhaps she was blocking the death or abandonment of her father, whom it seems was the one who followed her out the door after the dog and is the one who carred Hector (Morales!) back to the yard.

I wonder if we could petition Mr. Parriott to publish whatever scripts he has left? The Wikipedia entry says he has his own production company, but no contact information for it doesn't seem to be readily available on Google.

nwkeys01
nwkeys01's picture
Offline
Joined: 08/22/2009
ABC Tanks; DG possibilities

ABC is losing ground on some interesting time slots that DG might even have a chance in JAnuary

Eastwick, Wed. @ 10 (eventually right after lost, might be good because of flashbacks and character driven) but facing glee might be a hurt

The Forgotten; Tues 10pm; would have American Idol to deal with eventually
no real other competition, they had put sharktank also on tues.

Hank; Wed 8pm-830; time is too short

If DG does replace oneofthese ABC should at least replay a few episodes and not start directly with Eve ate the apple, AND ADVERTISE the show

Republibot 3.0
Republibot 3.0's picture
Offline
Joined: 12/27/2008
Apollo 11

Yeah, they were definitely echoing the A-11 landing, way too closely and entirely inappropriately. I was disappointed by that, even though the close-ups of the rockets firing was pretty cool looking.

I don't think Jen is a placeholder, and I do think Sharon is really dead. As they said in this episode, "It's always been about Zoe and Donner." They're the new Adam and Eve, or at the very least, the new Noah and his unnamed wife. Ultimately, I think the reason Sharon died in the first place was to make room for Zoe.

The Artist Formerly Known As Republibot 3.0

neorandomizer
neorandomizer's picture
Offline
Joined: 06/27/2009
Venus God's kiln

So I just watched episode 12 Venus and it was good but not great. Now did anyone notice that the landing was almost like the Apollo 11 landing but instead of rocks on the LZ it was the wind that made them go to manual?

I am starting to think that you guys are reading too much into what Beta shows them, I think it is the only way it can communicate with them at this time. It would not surprise me that the visions will become more detailed and intelligible as more of the objects are picked up. It would also not surprise me that the reason each one was picked was that they could see the visions except for Jen. Jen is just a place holder for the lost women on Mars that they will pick up with Alpha.

So from what Eve is saying the powers that be have no idea what will happen once they have all the aliens. That is a hell of a thing too do, how do they know that once together that they would not do something really bad for mankind it does not have to be anything good. The aliens, earth spirits what ever they are might be the way the universe gets rid of us so the dolphins can take over the earth.

Republibot 3.0
Republibot 3.0's picture
Offline
Joined: 12/27/2008
Truth

Ah. So. What would Bega gain by doing this? Same thing Paula said they were all looking for in her prayer, "The Truth." There's a longstanding belief in Christianity that "The Truth Shall Set You Free." It's also a fairly common belief in psychotherapy: In essence, we all have things that we've done or seen or lived through or had done to us that affected our development, and shape our subsequent behavior sort of the way a scab forms over a wound, or a tree will grow around an obstruction...unless, of course, it's a palm tree. The theory is that if you can get through these coping and defence mechanisms and get to the root cause - the "truth" if you will - then by treating and resolving it, the defense and coping mechanisms go away. Thus, by treating the root cause rather than the symptoms, you can help the person.

It works on emotional stuff most of the time, though in actual practice the road to catharsis (Staring Bing Crosby and Bob Hope, with Dorothy Lamore) is a bit more convoluted than my simplistic explanation really conveys, and of course it doesn't affect physeological or biochemical problems like, say, Schizophrenia at all, but, in general, that's the concept.

Beta wants them to be fully fuctioning, actualized human beings. Wow. That's really good, Nwkeys, I hadn't thought of that, but suddenly I'm 99% sure you're at least partially right. Well done!

The Artist Formerly Known As Republibot 3.0

nwkeys01
nwkeys01's picture
Offline
Joined: 08/22/2009
important life events

Beta may not directly be guilt related

all of the hallucinations might not be guilt related exactly as in Paula's case, but each event changed the lives of the person/people involved
however they have come to terms (mostly) with that event, and it defined their personality

Hurricane Ophelia- Eve
Mars- Ted and Donner
Girl Sharron knew- possibly deeply affected Sharron
Baby-Zoe
Nadia's hallucination- someting important concerning her

Jen (lost looking girl) on the other hand seems to be the only one who is actively supressing entirely something that happened,
paula did not supress per sey, just remembered-it-differently-supressed

not sure what beta doing this might gain
insight on the people it interacts with? something else, testing their character perhaps
all by using defining moments in their lives

***
next episode is 13 the last one made that we know of so far. I don't think they would kill off zoe, she's supposed to still be their around neptune on the wy out to pluto.

Republibot 3.0
Republibot 3.0's picture
Offline
Joined: 12/27/2008
Blackout

Right, but the blackout is effectively directional, effectively below the spacecraft. While you do get some ionization above the vehicle, it's never nearly as bad as below it. Like I said, NASA's got these talk up/talk down satellites so they can generally talk to the shuttles all the way through re-entry, and since the Antares is *Above* the Crossbow, communications shouldn't be a problem *unless* we assume a vastly, vastly bigger field of plasma completely enveloping the spacecraft, which *might* be the case, but if so, it would have to be of far shorter duration than you'd find on a craft in our atmosphere.

Didn't quite follow what you were saying about Jen and the others. Can you restate it?

The Artist Formerly Known As Republibot 3.0

nwkeys01
nwkeys01's picture
Offline
Joined: 08/22/2009
comm blackout &beta

"The communications blackouts that affect spacecraft re-entering the Earth's atmosphere, which are also known as radio blackouts, ionization blackouts, or reentry blackouts, are caused by an envelope of ionized air around the craft, created by the heat from the friction of the craft against the atmosphere. The ionized air interferes with radio signals. "
~http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Communications_blackout

i am also begining 2 wonder if its not guilt but significant moments that make a person who they are, is important
and supressionmight also play a role
everyone exceptjen has accepted the moment or miracle, jen (girl at airport) she might have supressed it, everyone else didn't supress their's.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Status

Bleeding Heart does not have a status.

Latest Status Updates

Ginrummy Ray Harryhausen, Visual Effects Master, Dies Aged 92 2 weeks ago
SheldonCooper Iron Man 3 review will be live first thing in the morning! 2 weeks ago
SheldonCooper @Kevin Long Second, it reminds us to never stop looking to the future and trying to make it better. Everything Trek's ever stood for 3 weeks ago
SheldonCooper @Kevin Long Observing a fictional event like First Contact Day is, first and foremost, just fun. 3 weeks ago
Kevin Long @SheldonCooper: can you comemorate an event before it happens? Or what about celebrating an event that didn't, like September 13th, 1999? 3 weeks ago
SheldonCooper @Kevin Long according to Star Trek, April 5, 2063 will be the day we make FC with the Vulcans. Thus, April 5 is FC day 4 weeks ago
Kevin Long @SheldonCooper: Huh? First contact day? 5 weeks ago