Skip to Content

EPISODE REVIEW: Defying Gravity: “Rubicon” (Episode 5)

Republibot 3.0's picture

The show has been steadily getting better. I know some people have criticized the show as it tends towards melodrama more than SF, but the fact of the matter is that they’re living on a space ship, and they’ve got a lot of time to kill. Whether you want it or not, you’re going to get a lot of melodramatic crap, just ask anyone who’s ever lived in a Co-Ed dorm. This week in particular, the scale tilts in favor of the soap opera stuff, rather than the more traditional skiffy stuff, but truth be told, I actually kind of liked it. We learn a lot more about the characters than we knew last week, the dynamics between them are building, and this felt like a nice intermezzo between the initial batch and whatever’s coming next.

PLAY BY PLAY

2047
Shaw and Jen are dating, more or less openly it seems. The Antares cadets get their comparative rankings to see who’s in the top of the program and who isn’t, and we’re reminded that there’s more than just 8 cadets, there’s a whole slew of ‘em in addition to the ones we’re following. While this has always been the case, we really haven’t seen the others since the episode where Wassenfelder almost drowned. Our main characters don’t do well. Jen places high, but Zoe is 28th on the ranking, and Wassenfelder is dead last. Shaw and Donner come in 12th and 13th respectively. They realize that Goss is screwing with the results, and go to confront him. “I’ve been on Mars.”

“Yes, I know, I was there.”
“No, you were in the Zeus giving orders, I was actually on Mars, he was on Mars” [Points at Shaw.] “Now, I might be willing to tolerate second on that ranking because Ted Shaw is a hell of an astronaut, but there is no way in hell I’m thirteenth.”

Goss admits he’s handicapping them because he doesn’t want them on the mission, he doesn’t even want them connected to it. Too much baggage, he says, looking at Donner’s baseball. They leave. Eve, who was on hand for this, senses, something is wrong here, and pokes in to it. Donner heads back to his class, obviously upset, and can’t find the right materials. Finally, after flailing around looking for schematics for a while, he freaks out and hurls a baseball at the back of the room and storms out.

Zoe, meanwhile, is dejected about her position in the ranking, and contemplates leaving the program entirely, having the baby, and teaching high school geology or something lame like that. Jen keeps pushing her to have an abortion, and reluctantly she meets with a doctor. This is done on the sly, because, of course, abortion is illegal in 2047. He tells her that in Europe, only one woman in a thousand has a negative reaction to the procedure, but doesn’t actually say what the procedure is. She tells him she isn’t sure she wants to go ahead, he says ‘call me if you want to,’ and leaves.

While pondering what to do, Zoe’s mom shows up, just a shambling, alcoholic mess of a woman, railing on about astrology and her husband leaving her for a young lab assistant and blah blah blah. Zoe is frustrated by this, but her mom continues to auntie mame about the place with her outrageously bad plastic surgery and her outlandishly large nose and her entirely-too-young-for-her haircut. She’s a mess. She insists Zoe take her to Major Toms, so she does, and immediately embarrasses her daughter by introducing herself a s a friend and trying to do tarot readings in public. Zoe gets pissed and leaves.

Donner comes to the bar, and Zoe’s mom recognizes him. They get to talking and she gives him a tarot reading and talks to him about being haunted by his past. Then her husband calls and she leaves. Evram comes in and gives Donner back his baseball. Donner thanks him, and Evram says there’s a rumor that there were two astronauts dating against the rules. A few days before their mission, they went to a baseball game and the guy caught the ball, gave it to the girl. She took it with them to mars, and she didn’t make it back, and now the guy can’t bring himself to let go of it. Of course, that’s just the rumor. I might be wrong about it.
“You are. She caught the ball, not me.”

Eve, meanwhile, goes to inspect the Mars Mission records, and finds that the

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Republibot 3.0
Republibot 3.0's picture
Offline
Joined: 12/27/2008
The Astronautical Ghost of Christmas Past

I've been wondering about the dead astronauts too. I mean, they actually *CAST* an actress to play the girl, she's been in 2 or 3 episodes so far in some form, I can't imagine they'd go to all that trouble and not have it pay off in some way.

I expect she/ they *ARE* dead, but that at the end of the season "Beta' will end up using her as an avatar to talk to Donner.

The Artist Formerly Known As Republibot 3.0

nwkeys01
nwkeys01's picture
Offline
Joined: 08/22/2009
Spaceship size and other stuff

From the videos it is a very impressively large spaceship, though.

And I hope no cows on venus, I still not sure when that will come up later, or the tattoo on Zoe's back, which looks northwestern Native American (of course it could just be because she is a canadian actress. Turns out she was on stargate: atlantis and played a major role on dead like me)

Is it even posible that the other astronauts on mars somehow survived, and the Antares are suppossed to save them or something?

Republibot 3.0
Republibot 3.0's picture
Offline
Joined: 12/27/2008
Probably not.

Spacecraft on TV shows and movies are designed to look cool, not to be feasable, with some very rare exceptions, most of them from B5. You're probably right, it's not carying enough fuel, though we don't know what they're using as an engine, nor what they're using as reaction mass, and we don't know how many of those pods on its flanks are fuel.

If it's supposed to be a chemical system, ain't no way.
If it's supposed to be a NERVA or LANTR system, it still wouldn't work, but it's at least closer.
If it's supposed to be a plasma system, then it probably *would* work
If it's supposed to be an ion engine, then they've got way more than enough reaction mass, but it won't work because IEs are so slow it'd take 'em 18 months just to get to the moon, and God knows how long to get to Venus...

The Artist Formerly Known As Republibot 3.0

neorandomizer
neorandomizer's picture
Offline
Joined: 06/27/2009
a nit pick

ships still not big enough to carry all the reaction mass it needs.

Republibot 3.0
Republibot 3.0's picture
Offline
Joined: 12/27/2008
Yeah, well done!

I really am impressed. Good job! Would that most SF shows put as much effort in to putting these things in to their shows as you've put in to figuring 'em out.

The Artist Formerly Known As Republibot 3.0

nwkeys01
nwkeys01's picture
Offline
Joined: 08/22/2009
Velocity is SCIENCE!!!

And if you take the 14 million mailes difference, and say they've travel for about maybe 30 or so days, it puts them at about 20,000 mph which is a perfectly reasonable velocity in that the math would be right.
I think that was the velocity of the Saturn/ Apollo Moon missions. So an object traveling at that speed would propbably leave the orbit of earth.

At least it wasn't an illogical speed like it was going aster than light or something.

AMybe one thing the show got right scientifically. (except for the velcro clothes and mag shampoo which I think NASA should look into)

Republibot 3.0
Republibot 3.0's picture
Offline
Joined: 12/27/2008
A-hah!

Well, kiddo, you just paid for your time on here in my book. That's a very good observation, and I'd totally missed it about the rabbit embryo. I think I'll make a note of that in the review itself. Thanks!

The Artist Formerly Known As Republibot 3.0

nwkeys01
nwkeys01's picture
Offline
Joined: 08/22/2009
Time Lag/

skip

nwkeys01
nwkeys01's picture
Offline
Joined: 08/22/2009
Time Lag/

Well, if you noticed, they mentioned the rabbit embryo was like 27 days old, and tht was just an episode or two before when we last saw the embryos. It was hard to catch but they mentioned it.

Maybe it was a subliminal thing of Goss that basically said, your not getting on the mission, so you don't have a chance of wearing a red suit like the other candidates.
This along with their scores being relatively lower than some.

Republibot 3.0
Republibot 3.0's picture
Offline
Joined: 12/27/2008
Pets and Plot Points

@ Neo: Good point. I think though Shaw kind of screwed up there, he was trying to be considerate towards his own people, and show that he was a very different kind of commander than Goss was. Meant well, even if it hadn't been thought through very well.

@ nwkeys01: NASA really hasn't done any long term missions where it would come up. Prior to the ISS, the longest NASA mission was Skylab 4 at just under 90 days. The Shuttle's average mission time is 10 days. It can do two weeks safely, three in an emergency, but that's it.

I doubt NASA would allow a pet on an interplanetary spacecraft, simply becuase of the additional cost of maintaining it, and the potential unpredictability it would add to the mission ("Oh crap, Jerry's dog went nuts again and bit Steve, then wizzed all over the secondary electrical conduits. So Jerry's torn up fairly bad, the dog fried himself in the process, there's hair all over the place, the place smells of fried dog, and I can't turn around without bumping in to little turd-asteroids up here.") If we ever attempt to colonize the lagranges or the planets, however, it'll be a necessity.

In fact, if *I* were setting up a base on the moon or another planet or whatever, I'd make a point of shipping some animals along just to get a broader crossection of how the low gravity in situ affects animals. If chimpanzees can't have babies in lunar gravity, it's a fair bet humans can't either. But I suspect that food animals - chickens and fish and stuff - would probably come well before pets.

The Artist Formerly Known As Republibot 3.0

nwkeys01
nwkeys01's picture
Offline
Joined: 08/22/2009
NASA & PEts for long term Missions

I agree, this episode was pretty good. A character-oriented episode.
And the thing with the rabbit embryo made me wonder about pNAsa using pets for long term missions. I mean they would provide companionship and fertilizer for the greenhouse.
For some strange reason they never show a "next time" at the end of the show

neorandomizer
neorandomizer's picture
Offline
Joined: 06/27/2009
not bad

This episode was good for character building and I think it did move the main story arc a little. If the White House (that's where the NSC is) was involved in the cover up about what really happened on Mars it most likely has to do with beta. Also beta seems to be actively helping the crew get to Venus so it must really want to get there that's why it showed Donner the bad filter. You maybe right about what Zoe does it would make sense. From a psychological point of view Shaw did not do Evram or Donner any favors by giving the stuff back.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Status

Bleeding Heart does not have a status.

Latest Status Updates

Ginrummy Ray Harryhausen, Visual Effects Master, Dies Aged 92 1 week ago
SheldonCooper Iron Man 3 review will be live first thing in the morning! 2 weeks ago
SheldonCooper @Kevin Long Second, it reminds us to never stop looking to the future and trying to make it better. Everything Trek's ever stood for 2 weeks ago
SheldonCooper @Kevin Long Observing a fictional event like First Contact Day is, first and foremost, just fun. 2 weeks ago
Kevin Long @SheldonCooper: can you comemorate an event before it happens? Or what about celebrating an event that didn't, like September 13th, 1999? 3 weeks ago
SheldonCooper @Kevin Long according to Star Trek, April 5, 2063 will be the day we make FC with the Vulcans. Thus, April 5 is FC day 3 weeks ago
Kevin Long @SheldonCooper: Huh? First contact day? 4 weeks ago