Skip to Content

EPISODE REVIEW: Defying Gravity: “Eve Ate The Apple” (Episode 9, Not broadcast in the US)

Republibot 3.0's picture

As anyone reading this knows, the network has more-or-less abandoned “Defying Gravity,“ and made a hokey announcement that episode 8 was the “Season Finale,“ when in fact there’s at least four more episodes in the can. I’d asked our foreign readers to pitch in, but so far no dice. In the meantime, astute Republibot-in-Training “nwkeys01” actually found the episode online. Special thanks, man (I assume). We will now all pause for 15 seconds to sing your praises.

My original intention was to review the episode for some dead space on the site in November, but as my intended content for today turned out to be illegally infringing on someone else’s property (And again, guys, sorry about that, and thanks for letting me know), I’ve had to take it down. Then I got to thinking, “Well, what the hell? Why not review it? We were damn near the only website in the ‘States bothering to cover the show before, now we can be the *only* one covering it! Woo-hoo. If you, the reader, would like to watch it *before* reading my review, go here http://www.casttv.com/shows/defying-gravity/eve-ate-the-apple/zrto7z

PLAY BY PLAY

2017 - Eve is born in New Orleans, Louisiana.

2021 - Eve, age four, picks up one of her dad’s violins and composes a song on the spot. Her dad proclaims her a prodigy - he’s a musician himself - and teaches her the classics. She continues to play her first song pretty much every day. After a short, but promising career in New Orleans, Eve is accepted to Julliard, and moves to New York as a ‘tween, she barely sees her family, but she has a bright future ahead of her.

2033 - Hurricane Ophelia strikes New Orleans and the city is devastated in pretty much the same way as it was with Katrina in 2005 and Betsy in 1965. Eve’s family is killed. Eve is devastated, and refuses to ever play violin again.

2038 - Eve is now a member of the American Crisis Corps, and she’s part of the relief efforts in Nazca, Peru, where there have been massive floods and landslides and loss of life. Meanwhile, a Bertrand Corporation radio observatory notices some focused signals coming from a specific location on Mars - Gusev Crater ( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gusev_crater ) - which is being beamed specifically at Nazca, Peru. The observatory techs name the Martian source “Alpha” and the Peruvian receptor “Beta,” and quickly realize that Beta is actually responding.

Meanwhile, in Peru, Even is having a hard time adjusting to the high altitude, she’s having a hard time breathing, sleeping, eating, whatever. She’s on the edge of exhaustion. One night, while not able to sleep, she hears a violin playing *her* tune on a plateau in the distance, though no one else can hear it. She wanders off alone, climbs the plateau, then walks across the top of it to an unmarked spot where the hallucinatory sound is overwhelmingly loud, and she starts digging. At just that moment, helicopters and military-looking goons (Who may not actually be military) show up, arrest, and interrogate her. Whoever they are, they’re working for the Bertrand corporation, and they clearly don’t believe her story until she tells them about the music. Then they have her show them where the sound is coming from, and dig up “Beta” - a golden, glowing, fractal kind of blob-thing that just sorta’ hovers there. The Goonsquad commander tells Eve to go back to her camp and forget all about this, and tell no one about it, with an implicit threat in his words. She hastily retreats.

Back at camp, Eve is even worse off than before, distracted, depressed, relentlessly exhausted, unable or unwilling to eat. It becomes apparent that she’s probably dying by degrees, and she speaks of feeling like a part of herself was missing. After several days or weeks of this, the goodsquad commander shows up and asks her to come with him: “Beta” is dying, and while they don’t know what the hell it is, or why it’s dying, their eggheads suspect it’s because she’s not there with it. She goes, and from then on, she’s in the Betram corp.
2042 - A manned mission to Mars lands in Gusev crater, to retrieve “Alpha“ and bring it to earth. The crew - or at least most of them - are not informed of the true purpose of their mission. Donner, Shaw, and Goss, Donner’s girlfriend, and a red shirt are involved, and as we all know, the girlfriend and red shirt both

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Republibot 3.0
Republibot 3.0's picture
Offline
Joined: 12/27/2008
More than that, you're *the* man.

Thank you, thank you, thank you for finding the episode for us! My review is online here http://www.republibot.com/content/episode-review-defying-gravity-%E2%80%...

nwkeys01
nwkeys01's picture
Offline
Joined: 08/22/2009
10!

yes I am a man.
found episode 10

http://www.megavideo.com/?d=YZMGNQBZ
haven't yet watched it but am about to.

Republibot 3.0
Republibot 3.0's picture
Offline
Joined: 12/27/2008
Thanks, Nwkeys01!

If you find an URL for episode 10 online, please do let us know, ok? I really appreciate your pointing out the last one to us!

nwkeys01
nwkeys01's picture
Offline
Joined: 08/22/2009
Ep. 10

Episode 10 won't be shown (outside the US) until October 2, looks like they're taking a week break but their are descrptions for up to episode 13 on wikipedia for the show.

Ep. 10- Deja Vu
Ep. 11- Solitary
Ep. 12- Venus
Ep. 13- Kiss

these episodes will be run on SPACE channel for CTV ( mainly shows scifi, and other similar stuff)
Oct 2 episode @ 8:00 PM

Republibot 3.0
Republibot 3.0's picture
Offline
Joined: 12/27/2008
Why avoid it?

Just curious. What's the aversion?

(It's not a great show by any means, but it is nice to see someone from outside the ghetto trying to do a ghetto show)

wolf
wolf's picture
Offline
Joined: 07/16/2009
Grrrrrr

No you all are actually making me want to watch this show. *whimpers* And I've been trying so hard to avoid it.

Republibot 3.0
Republibot 3.0's picture
Offline
Joined: 12/27/2008
stripped down.

Not surprising that some Catholics would be confused by their own philosophy: It's vastly, vastly more convoluted and difficult to follow than the stripped down, high-octane, full-custom Gospel we new world Protestants follow. The version of the Rapture that's au courant in most protestant churches (Not counting the Lutherans, the Anglicans, or the big old-world protestants like that) is the Barton Stone/ Alexander Campbell one, which basically started in the early 19th century, and that was largely a new world religious expression that cropped up here alone. (Though missionaries did cause it to filter back to the old world thereafter). It's really unlikely (Though not impossible) that a Catholic would be using Stone/Campbellite terminology for such things.

By the way, are we *sure* Paula's catholic? That might be an unfair assumption based on her hispanic heritage. I mean, Edward James Olmos was born and raised Baptist...

neorandomizer
neorandomizer's picture
Offline
Joined: 06/27/2009
only the Gospels are well gospel.

That's what I was trying to point out Paula's reaction is not in keeping with what she would have been taught as a Catholic. That does not mean she couldn't react that way but it is unlikely. It can be only one of two things a psychological problem with Paula or the writers do not know what they are writing about. Your point about forgiveness of sin and gilt is also correct in fact some would argue that without gilt you could not or would not ask to be forgiven.

Even some Catholics are confused by some of the finer points of Catholic philosophy. But she would know that only the Gospels are considered reveled truth and the rest of the new testament and the old are stories to reinforce the teachings in the Gospels.

Republibot 3.0
Republibot 3.0's picture
Offline
Joined: 12/27/2008
I'm inclined to believe you're right...

...but we have very little proof as yet. Basically, the only people who've expressed any kind of observable faith thus far are AJ and Paula. Shaw was raised Buddhist, but evidently doesn't practice. Wassenfelder could have some kind of faith in the fundamental somethingorotherness of the universe, and I think that's implicit in his character. Donner just seems to have faith that he's the right guy for the job. The rest of them? Not so much. I suppose Evram might have some implicit faith in Psychology.

Oh, something else that's bugging me: Paula's all gaga over the Rapture. I'm not Catholic, so I don't know this for certain, but it's my understanding that Catholics don't get all obsessive over the Rapture as we protestants, do, and they tend to believe in it in a vastly different way than we do as well. So it's odd that Paula would be, you know, talking like a Baptist all of a sudden...

nwkeys01
nwkeys01's picture
Offline
Joined: 08/22/2009
Trust

I think Maybe the reason Jen cannot see Beta is closely related to R# and that B5 Vorlon stuff.

Both Jen and Wassenfelder have not had hallucinations. However Wassenfelder can see beta, EJn can't, so lets compare the two.

Wassenfelder is a theorectical physicist, he trys to prove that things WE HAVE KNOW IDEA of existing exist, which takes a lot of faith. A lot of science is like that, trusting in something you don't know in order to know more about it.

That might be the main difference between him and Jen. Jen is probably a true skeptic about everything. If she can't see it, how can she be sure it exists. A what is is, type of person. Not much guilt for her because of this viewpoint.

Republibot 3.0
Republibot 3.0's picture
Offline
Joined: 12/27/2008
I had a really dirty joke I decided not to use

you know, about women, and first and the verb in between, but I'll leave that alone.

Well, the odds are we won't find out a lot about this stuff. The show isn't evidently getting boffo ratings anywhere, and I doubt they're going to get a second season out of it, but, yeah, I *do* think we're gonna' see more of Donners dead girlfriend.

What if "Beta" is part of a corprate entity, who's abilities increase as propinquity increases. So now "Beta" can only use vague memories of shame to communicat, but put Beta and Gamma in the same room, and suddenly they're capable of taking more direct control of the halucinations and whatnot?

I do expect it's some kind of "Fix man, fix the planet" thing.

Something that annoyed me about this episode, but I"m not sure if it's a writing flaw or a deliberate detail, is that Paula says she has no guilt about anything because she's forgiven. That's not really how it works. Forgiveness and Guilt are not the same thing. "Forgiveness" simply means God won't hold you accountable for what you did, "Guilt" however implies personal emotional responses to whatever you did, and that don't go away. This could be a misunderstanding on the part of the writers (It's a fairly common one among people not raised in some traditional religion), or it could be yet another symptom of Paula's wigout. They've been implying for several weeks now that she's having a crisis of faith, and her public professions of it might well be a "Protest too much" kinda' thing.

Nwkys01, please let us know if you find the next episode, ok?

Falconlady
Offline
Joined: 09/03/2009
The Girlfriend

So maybe Alpha on Mars protected or connected with Sharon and she didn't die and instead has ascended or something like that. (This would explain why there is a real actress cast for the role) Then Donner can get connected with Beta somehow on Venus and then Sharon-Alpha and Donner-Beta "knock space boots" and together they'll create the new ascended being race that won't kill the planets or get bent and become one with Gaia. Note that in this creation story the women come first.

'Specially crafted to drive republibots nuts.

Thanks much to nwkeys01 for sharing.

neorandomizer
neorandomizer's picture
Offline
Joined: 06/27/2009
good but..

Nothing in the show so far says beta and the other cheap special effects are Gaia. It does not fit with the locations of some of the unknowns, what does being in the rings of Saturn have to do with a planetary spirit. And we all know from Final Fantasy: The Spirit Within that having another planet's spirit on earth is bad.

All joking aside I am sure they are going for the aliens are going to heal the earth or man or both. The writers kept hinting toward that new age sort of crap.

Now R3 the difference between AJ’s freak out and Paula’s is that AJ did not start talking about the apocalypse he just tried to kill himself in an expensive and unusual way. People that believe the end is near are irritating and usually dangerous Jonestown and the Branch Davidians are proof of that. I do not mind that she would take it as a sign from God, I might think so to but to jump head long to the rapture is coming is disturbing and counter to what the Catholic church teaches on the possibility of first contact. And since they made a point of showing that she is a good Catholic girl why they now have her reacting like a cultist I do not understand. I would think that before she left someone from the church would have talked to her about the church’s stand on life in space. Unless it’s the writers just being your standard anti christian liberals.

Jen not seeing beta might be what you think R3, she does not have the moral or intellectual chops to see it. She has been shown as your standard issue liberal airhead. Now it is interesting that like Jen, Wassenfelder did not have visions but can see beta that maybe a hint as to what is wrong with Jen.

It was a good episode but I do not know if I will like the direction they will take the story from here.

sysadmin 2.0
sysadmin 2.0's picture
Offline
Joined: 12/23/2008
Oyarsa?

I say this having never seen an episode (We're not monolithic here at the 'Bot, we all have lives outside of the site...), but this concept is rather similar to the Oyarsa in C.S. Lewis' Space Trilogy, isn't it?

All planets have Oyarsa (ruling spirits), and the one on Malacandra (Earth) is bent, and they are invisible to those who are incapable of belief...

Republibot 3.0
Republibot 3.0's picture
Offline
Joined: 12/27/2008
Stupid or Smart, it doesn't matter...

...we're the only game in town.

And you know, I don't think we're doing all that badly. I mean, we've had the ability to wipe out human life on earth for 60 years now, we haven't used it. We've avoided massive wars. We've managed to maintain a population far in excess of nature's ability to grow food or allocate resources. That's pretty impressive for a bunch of monkeys, really. That said, there is a learning curve in these things...

nwkeys01
nwkeys01's picture
Offline
Joined: 08/22/2009
Gaia & enviromental message

The whoel gaia thing again goes with eve beign told that Beta is "dying"
many peope today say that the earth is "dying"

one very good example this show gives is the destruction of the great coral reef and cyanobacteria. Pretty much 50 yrs from now, we here in the prescent didn't do enough and the earth is falling apart possibly.

And maybe since some other planets have a "gaia" spirit,

Me if I controled the ending I would have the parts being brought together to form a human mafestation of the Gaia or maybe like stated above the Beta gaia just needs help to heal and save the earth.

Humans are a stupid species at time.

Planets with objects
Mars- Alpha
Earth-Beta
Venus-Gamma
Mercury-Delta
Europa- Epsilon
Saturn's rings- Zeta
Pluto- Eta

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Status

Bleeding Heart does not have a status.

Latest Status Updates

Jake Was Here Bunch of French spammers clogging up the forums. God only knows why. 20 hours ago
nwkeys01 anyone willing to review the tv show "Once Upon A Time", I've heard it's good, but I'm not good at making reviews, and haven't seen it yet. 3 days ago
nwkeys01 surprised the N.C amendment was called to a vote. Based on supreme court cases and 14th amendment it is unconstitutional. 3 days ago
Ginrummy Obscure science joke: "Dr. Schrodinger, you got a package in the mail today. I took the libery of opening it. Why did you order a dead cat?" 4 days ago
Ginrummy There's a HUGE spider in my house. So do I deal with it or just let it stay and eat some cockroaches? 1 week ago
Jake Was Here Conservatives hating on MLP? Where do we go from here? 1 week ago
shhhimbatman YJ ep 24 review up. I'm trying to catch up now. It's good to be back. 1 week ago
Ginrummy Vin Diesel says new "Riddick" movie (which just finished filming) is on track for a tentative release date of January 2013. 2 weeks ago
Scorpious wants to buy R3 a beer 2 weeks ago
Ginrummy I'll go to France and ask someone to "do something 'French' for me." They'll probaby just say "Stupid American!" and I'll reply "Thank you!" 2 weeks ago
Ginrummy XKCD cartoon for Altas Shrugged at http://xkcd.com/1049/ 2 weeks ago
Scorpious @Republibot 3.0 My birthday too ;-) 2 weeks ago
Republibot 3.0 Today is Larry Niven's birthday. He's 74. 2 weeks ago
SheldonCooper @Republibot 3.0 No you didn't, we just had a Dave and Maddie moment 2 weeks ago
Republibot 3.0 Well, it would appear as though I really screwed the pooch this time on the forums... 3 weeks ago