Skip to Content

EPISODE REVIEW: Defying Gravity: “Bacon” (Episode 6)

Republibot 3.0's picture

So here we are at the end of the first half of the season, and I find I’m much more invested in this show than I anticipated. Yeah, I’m not unaware of its failings, most of them related to the technical side of things, but I find I’m responding well to the very decompressed storytelling, the slow character arcs, the relaxed pace. It’s not ‘ohmigod the Prosthetic Forehead Aliens of planet Cliché VII are going to destroy civilization’ ever week, nor is it ‘ohmigod, the Prosthetic Forehead Aliens of planet Tedium X need to learn an important lession about life, taught in the most didactic way possible.’ Instead, it’s more workaday. I just sorta’ like that.

A lot of websites decried this series as “chick stuff’ or “Grey’s Anatomy in Space,” and the advance word was, of course, that this show was intended as a sort of “Gateway drug” to get women hooked on SF. I don’t know if that’s true or not, and I don’t know if it’s worked or not (I assume it wouldn’t), but I think a much more useful - and possibly unintentional - aspect of the show is that it might serve to introduce some of the more stereotypical male members of the audience (Trekies, I’m looking at you) to the concept that human drama isn’t a bad or scary or shameful thing, and that if you can fit it in with the gee gosh wow stuff, it just makes things better all around. So, if it’s intended as “SF 101” for chicks, or “Emotions 101” for mouth breathing dudes, I find I don’t really care either way, I’m just kind of digging the show.

That said, tonight was a pretty hard episode for me to watch, and I could definitely see a younger version of my self abandoning this series for ever after what they did tonight, but we’ll get to that below.

PLAY BY PLAY

2047

After stringing us along for two and a half weeks, Zoe takes the abortion pill. As fate and politically motivated scripts would have it, she happens to take it on the day that the cadets are doing a training section on trauma. They’re taken to a hospital and divied up in to groups. Some of the old timers take bets on when the notoriously vasovagal Donner will puke or black out. Paula and Wassenfelder are assigned to watch a druggie taking some new untraceable designer chemical, so they do, and of course they get to bickering, she calls him a poser, he calls her a religious fanatic. Wassenfelder gets along swell with the druggie, but Paula clearly has no sympathy for the guy.

Donner and Evram end up getting involved in a gunshot wound case, which the resident surgeon is botching because there’s so little gun violence in the future that he doesn’t know what to do. As the victim codes, Evram just takes over the surgery, and Donner assists, and he doesn’t pass out, though he’s clearly only barely holding it together.

The druggie codes, and the doctor can’t bring him back, but Paula won’t let it slide and does CPR on the guy for a while, just because there’s a chance. Claire, meanwhile, asks Evram out for a drink, and he says ‘yeah.’

Jen and Zoe don’t do much important, but Zoe talks to a pregnant doctor lady about regrets and choices (sigh), and the doctor excuses Zoe because she isn’t feeling well. Donner leaves, too. He gets to talking to her about a pig his uncle slaughtered when he was a kid, and therefore he can’t stand the sight of blood, and Zoe passes out, obviously in great pain. Donner picks her up and carries her back in to the hospital, where they immediately give her care, and Jen immediately fesses up to the pregnant doctor lady that Zoe took an abortion pill. AJ overhears this, but says he won’t betray her, and when things are better, he goes to tell Donner everything is ok.

When Zoe wakes up, Eve is there, telling she’s had an emergency hysterectomy, and that the cover story will be “you had a cyst that burst, and we removed it.” Everything is all nicely covered up.

2052

Evram is taking a blood sample from Donner, and having trouble doing it. It takes him six tries to hit the vein, and even though Paula was bugging him, that ain’t right. He tells Donner it’s a weird reaction of his pain meds for his back, lying, of course. Jen,

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Republibot 3.0
Republibot 3.0's picture
Offline
Joined: 12/27/2008
Truth

Yeah, well, I guess what I really expected was that they wouldn't bother to lie about something no one cared about anyway.

"We're taking the show off the air, but we'll bring it back six months from now, we promise." (Lie)

"We're taking the show off the air because we were just burning off episodes anyway, and no one is watching it" (Truth)

The Artist Formerly Known As Republibot 3.0

neorandomizer
neorandomizer's picture
Offline
Joined: 06/27/2009
@R3

You expect the truth from ABC, well I have a bridge slightly used for sale.

Republibot 3.0
Republibot 3.0's picture
Offline
Joined: 12/27/2008
You know, I just realizied....

You know, I just realized something: the network said they weren't cancelling "Defying Gravity," they were just putting it on hiatus, and would run the remaining episodes come the spring. Well, here we are, and there's been no mention of scheduling the show, even in a little-watched death-slot to burn off the remaining ones.

Huh.

The Artist Formerly Known As Republibot 3.0

nwkeys01
nwkeys01's picture
Offline
Joined: 08/22/2009
Bova Search and return

They didn't plan on being on venus long. In the story the main character's brother had gone to venus on a mission and dies, and the guy's father cut him off, and offered a multimillion $$$ reward to go to venus and return the remains.

the rest of the details I don't want to spoil to anyone readiing the book.

Republibot 3.0
Republibot 3.0's picture
Offline
Joined: 12/27/2008
ROVs are cheaper and safer

and they're a very useful tool besides, but you don't own a place until you put your boots on the soil, you know? Granted, that's a lot more expensive, as I'll be the first person to admit, but we've been sending off unmanned probes for 35 years now, and at some point you need to stop and say "Dammit, let's do something sexy again!"

The Artist Formerly Known As Republibot 3.0

Republibot 3.0
Republibot 3.0's picture
Offline
Joined: 12/27/2008
Lead would work...

IT's kind of a stopgap situation, and it seriously limits the time you could spend there. I wonder why he didn't just use some kind of refrigeration syste or somewhat more open-ended heat dumping system. Interesting.

The blimp would definitely work, and given the density involved, it wouldn't even have to be very big.

Rockets on Venus are problematic. You don't get as much bang for your buck, given the high ambient temperature of the planet, and if you're using something with a combination of fuels that'll work on earth or the moon, on venus, unless the temperature of the exhaust is higher than the background temperature, you don't have a rocket at all, just an amazingly inefficient refrigerator (As Fred Phol pointed out once).

Myself, if it were an expeditionary mission, I'd use a submarinish spacecraft with a big pusher plate/re-entry shield, then use it as an Nuclear Pulse Rocket to get back in to orbit. No problem there, and containing a few small 1 or 2 Kt nukes is much easier than hundreds of thousands of gallons of fuel, and a lot safer than solid rockets. (Crazy to think that a nuke is safer than a solid rocket, but there it is!)

The Artist Formerly Known As Republibot 3.0

nwkeys01
nwkeys01's picture
Offline
Joined: 08/22/2009
Bova's solution

It was pretty much ceramic metal blimps, with a rocket launch assist

He also used stuff like submarines, at least the small landing craft and used lead honeycombed through the structure. Venus surface is hot enough to melt lead, so the smaller craft used this heat to melt the lead and then expelled the lead out of the back and also therfore expelling the heat with it, for about as long as it had lead.

neorandomizer
neorandomizer's picture
Offline
Joined: 06/27/2009
ROV vs DSV

You maybe right R3 but I was just thinking how not many DSV's are built anymore because it's safer and cheaper to do it with ROV's. I have a tendency to blow off Venus as not to useful so I can be biased about it.

now i have to read Venus by Ben Bova i bought it for 50 cents at a used book store and have not got to it. I was rereading some known space stories because i got neutron star cheap at the same store.

Republibot 3.0
Republibot 3.0's picture
Offline
Joined: 12/27/2008
How did Bova solve it?

The mission profile they showed in the first episode showed them going to mercury, venus, mars, jupiter, saturn, and uranus, IIRC (Which I might not). If that's the case, "Pluto" might simply be a mythological name they slapped on one of the landers (Such as "Zeus" and "Caliope" from the Mars Expedition). On that note, I wonder what the V-lander is called? They haven't mentioned the name yet...

The Artist Formerly Known As Republibot 3.0

nwkeys01
nwkeys01's picture
Offline
Joined: 08/22/2009
Venus

Ben bova soved the problem nicely in his book.

The Antares also plan on heading to Pluto, because in a previous clip, you can make out the lander labeled Pluto

Republibot 3.0
Republibot 3.0's picture
Offline
Joined: 12/27/2008
Venus is *NOT* Stupid

Keep in mind that by the time this show takes place, they'll have had SEVENTY YEARS of 'bots on Venus. Probably they're reaching the end of what they can tell us.

Secondly, a manned landing on Venus would be considerably easier than a manned landing on the moon or Mars. The atmosphere is as dense as an ocean, so you clip the outside of it, it eats up your inertia, you start to go slower and slower, just like re-entry on earth, and at a certain point the atmospheric density is high enough that your spacecraft just floats like a submarine. You can maneuver around with very little power - again like a sub - you don't need to expend much rocket fuel to do it, *and* you can cover vast distances with just a small propeller, given how thick the air is.

Added to which, the atmosphere is so dense that you're actually getting more radiation shielding on Venus than you are on earth. Of course your ship has to be insulated for high heat, high pressure, and protected from the caustic crap in the air there, *but* it's do-able, and safe. None of this "Precarious landing on one pillar of flame" crap.

Getting back *UP* again is a problem - you can't use Rockets for it - but it's not insurmountable.

The Artist Formerly Known As Republibot 3.0

neorandomizer
neorandomizer's picture
Offline
Joined: 06/27/2009
Wassenfelder

Paula and Zoe are doing the Venus landing so Wassenfelder can code and it would not mean a thing. Shaw and Donner are the key hope the show lasts long enough for us to find out.

note: maned landing on Venus is just stupid this is one case where a bot would be better the risk is to high.

Republibot 3.0
Republibot 3.0's picture
Offline
Joined: 12/27/2008
I'm not sure

I'm not sure if the halucinations are a way of forcing people to confront stuff, or if it's just a side effect. For instance, Zoe and Donner were both having dreams of her flying out of the ship and dying, then she had her suit malfunction and *almost* died, but since that situation, those dreams have gone away. Donner had halucinations of the ghosts of mars (Which is just fun to say), which led him to a water system error, which he fixed, and since then the ghosts have gone away.

I think Beta is just grabbing emotionally resonant images from their own minds, and using them to manipulate the crew to do things that will preserve their own lives. Zoe *would* have died, they *all* would have died from the water error, etc. Once the immediate problem is resolved, the halucinations stop.

I don't think it's an issue of benevolence, I don't think it's a case of AJ and Rollie not having any major issues, I think it's just that Beta needs Shaw and Donner there for some specific reason. I think Neorandomizer is right: that they've been tied up in this all along, without realizing it - that Beta was in some way tied up with the botched Mars mission from 10 years before.

The Artist Formerly Known As Republibot 3.0

nwkeys01
nwkeys01's picture
Offline
Joined: 08/22/2009
tests of beta, the cave

beta is really the acting role of pyschiatrist.
Forcing Zoe to come to grips with a terminated preganancy.

Having Jen take care of the rabbit baby and giving her guilt over Zoe and possibly a second chance

Donner's and Ted's guilt over Mars
Evram's post-war trauma
Not sure what Wasssenfelder, Nadia, and Paula, and their serious issues.

It is acting like the cave from the Star Wars movie. Ajay and Rollie aren't on the ship because they had no serious issues to deal with.

Beta does not seem to be a malignant entity at the moment. I don't think it would be trying to kill Paula. Maybe it knows during venus Wassenfelder will have a breakdown or something, and Paula will need to be there. It has happened before, like in H2IK.

neorandomizer
neorandomizer's picture
Offline
Joined: 06/27/2009
The unseen hand of beta

OK I have seen it now and I have some questions and thoughts. If Evram has TSS why did they not know before the fight. And if he does not then it means that beta is doing it and that leads to the question of why. Now one hint maybe the main damage to Paula was when the door closed for no reason. Now it could be that beta does not want Paula to pilot the Venus Lander and wants Donner to do it since he is the backup pilot. The question now become why does beta want Donner to pilot the lander and is beta going to take more steps to get rid of Paula.

Jen has proved herself to be a jerk in this one. She flouts a baby rabbit to a women she egged on to have an abortion and does not get why that might upset Zoe. Lets rub Zoe's face in it because Jen wants a baby what an ass. Is this one more step to Zoe's suicide attempt, maybe beta wants both Donner and Shaw on Venus.

Did you see the look on Shaw's face when Evram told him about the hallucination he knows it's beta. Now he knows 2 other people are being screwed with that makes 3 he knows of he does not know about Zoe hearing a crying baby or that she and Donner are having the same dream. So 4 of the crew are being communicated with by beta and beta might be trying to kill Paula.

neorandomizer
neorandomizer's picture
Offline
Joined: 06/27/2009
ratings

here are the latest ratings this show is not doing well.

http://www.variety.com/article/VR1118007354.html?categoryid=14&cs=1&quer...

I have not seen this weeks episode yet it is on in 30 minutes in my time zone. Just a thought on Zoe they had to do the abortion because she is hearing a baby crying and I bet that it's her gilt that beta is projecting back at her. Donner's dream of her doing the naked space walk might be that she is going to kill herself from her gilt so they might still be going the anti abortion route we will have to see.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Status

Bleeding Heart does not have a status.

Latest Status Updates

SheldonCooper Happy First Contact Day, everyone! 6 weeks ago
jamewages Hi to all of you 6 weeks ago
Mama Fisi Husband got a clean bill of health from the neurologist today. Yay! 12 weeks ago
Jim Stiles @Kevin Long: It is worse here. 16 weeks ago
Mama Fisi @Vaughn Banks Thank you, Vaughn. He's still having to be careful, but overall he's doing great. 16 weeks ago
Vaughn Banks @Mama Fisi I'm happy to hear your Husband is doing so much better. God bless you both. 17 weeks ago
neorandomizer Been playing with my new iphone all week, it's my first smart phone to bad its not made in the USA. 18 weeks ago